top of page

Overwhelmed By Heavyweight Project Methodologies?

Project management methodologies can sometimes feel like navigating a labyrinth with a blindfold on.

They often aren't written well, and generally jump all over the shop rather than explaining things sequentially and logically.

Each version they release just complicates things more as they try to self-justify their existance and completeness.

They also have A LOT of words...

Among the towering giants are PRINCE2 and PMBOK, casting long shadows over noob project managers.

Put these volumes in front of an aspiring PM, and they'll likely use them as a platform for their monitor, or try and get rid of them as quickly as possible.

Yet, while these frameworks set the gold standard and serve as important introductions, diving into their voluminous tomes can be an overwhelming experience.

Here’s why it’s worth reading the rule book—before you consider tossing it out of the window.

The Overwhelming Nature of Project Management Frameworks

Imagine being handed a set of encyclopaedias when all you wanted was a concise manual.

That’s what it feels like when you first encounter PRINCE2 and PMBOK.

These methodologies are comprehensive, to say the least, packed with a staggering amount of content, concepts, and detailed processes. Enrolling in a course on either can make your head spin faster than a teacup ride at a funfair.

However, there’s immense value in grappling with these frameworks. They provide a structured approach to project management, ensuring that nothing falls through the cracks.

So, while the size of the books and the sheer volume of information may seem daunting, persevering through them equips you with a robust foundation.

It's like reading the rule book before a game—it might seem tedious, but it makes you a better player in the long run.

PRINCE2: Adaptive Yet 'Old School'

PRINCE2 proudly touts its adaptability, and rightly so. It’s designed to be tailored to fit projects of any size and complexity. But let’s be honest—it’s also a bit 'old school'.

The framework has its roots in traditional project management practices, and while it has been updated to accommodate Agile practices, it can sometimes feel a bit like explaining the MCU to my nan.

Despite its traditional backbone, PRINCE2’s adaptability is not to be underestimated. It might not have the sleekness of a new model, but it gets the job done with a certain reliability.

The updates to integrate Agile practices show that PRINCE2 is evolving, albeit at its own pace.

PMBOK: The Comprehensive Guide

PMBOK, or the Project Management Body of Knowledge, is like the Swiss Army knife of project management. It’s packed with tools and techniques for every conceivable project management scenario.

If PRINCE2 is the reliable, slightly old-fashioned family car, then PMBOK is the fully-loaded SUV.

What makes PMBOK stand out is its exhaustive coverage of project management processes and knowledge areas. From integration and scope to time, cost, quality, human resources, communications, risk, procurement, and stakeholder management—PMBOK leaves no stone unturned. It’s the ultimate guidebook for project managers who crave a deep dive into every facet of their craft.

Yet, this comprehensive nature can be a double-edged sword.

The sheer volume of information can be overwhelming, especially for beginners. It’s like trying to drink from a fire hose. But once you get the hang of it, PMBOK equips you with the knowledge and skills to tackle even the most complex projects with confidence.

The Agile Conundrum

Speaking of Agile, it’s a bit of an enigma in the project management world.

Agile enthusiasts swear by its effectiveness, and for good reason. It excels in prioritising requirements and fostering a flexible, iterative approach to development.

However, calling Agile a project management methodology is like calling a spanner a complete toolbox. It’s incredibly useful, but it doesn’t cover everything.

Agile is fantastic for delivery, but it falls short when it comes to aspects like budgeting, pre-project planning, governance, and risk management. These are critical elements that PRINCE2 and PMBOK address comprehensively. Agile complements these methodologies rather than replaces them.

Think of Agile as the energetic younger sibling—full of innovative ideas and quick solutions, but lacking the comprehensive oversight and structure that age provides.

Striking a Balance

There’s no one-size-fits-all solution.

PRINCE2 and PMBOK offer thorough, structured approaches that ensure every aspect of a project is meticulously planned and managed.

Agile brings in a breath of fresh air with its flexible, adaptive delivery style.

The key is to strike a balance—leveraging the strengths of each methodology to suit the unique needs of your project.

So, while the hefty tomes of PRINCE2 and PMBOK might initially seem like a mountain to climb, they are important guides. And Agile? It’s the dynamic force that propels you forward once you have your plan in place. Together, they create a harmonious symphony of structure and flexibility, guiding your projects to success.

In conclusion, while the journey through the world of project management methodologies might be arduous, the knowledge and skills gained are invaluable.

Embrace the rule book, adapt to new practices, and blend methodologies to navigate your projects to success with confidence and finesse.


bottom of page